Mr. Chairman and distinguished members of this Committee, thank you for allowing
the National Organization for Rare Disorders (NORD) the opportunity to testify
before you today regarding funding for the Office of Rare Diseases (ORD) at
the National Institutes of Health (NIH). My name is Diane Dorman, Vice President
for Public Policy, and as a representative of NORD and the rare disease community,
I want to express my deep appreciation for everything this Committee has done
to ensure increased funding for biomedical research at the NIH.
Rare diseases are defined in statute as any disease, syndrome or disorder affecting
fewer than 200,000 people in the United States. Although the prevalence of each
of the 6,000 known "orphan" diseases is rare, in the aggregate, they
affect approximately 25 million Americans. According to National Commission
on Orphan Diseases (DHHS, 1989) estimates, only 30 percent of those patients
receive a diagnosis in three to five years after the onset of symptoms. Fifteen
percent, or approximately 3.7 million people, wait seven years or more.
Additionally, rare disease patients are particularly impacted by the cost of
diagnosis, treatment and ancillary support services that can reduce a family
to poverty. Patients must also often travel long distances to academic hospitals
to see the few specialists who work on their particular disease.
Rare "orphan" diseases include such better-known diseases as sickle
cell anemia, Tay-Sachs, hemophilia, Fanconi's anemia, Tourette syndrome, Lou
Gehrig's disease and scleroderma. They also include obscure diseases such as:
- Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease - a hereditary neurological
disorder marked by progressive muscle weakness and atrophy, particularly in
the legs;
- Trisomy 13 syndrome - a chromosomal disorder in which
an extra copy of all or part of chromosome 13 is present, resulting in a variable
range of developmental delays, retardation and widespread anatomical and internal
organ abnormalities;
- Sturge-Weber syndrome - a condition characterized by excessive
blood vessel growth, accumulation of calcium in the brain, and seizures;
- Fibrodysplasia osssificans progressiva (FOP) - a condition
that transforms muscles, tendons, and ligaments into bone. Internal organs
are not affected and so patients can live normal life spans unless they "die
from complications secondary to their immobility, like pneumonia, falls, or
choking on aspirated food."
- Progeria - a genetic disorder affecting one in 8 million
newborns worldwide causing premature aging. Within a year after birth, growth
rate slows and their appearance begins to change. Children become bald and
their skin ages dramatically. They suffer with symptoms typical of the elderly.
Death occurs on average at age 13. There are no diagnostic tests or treatments.
In 1983, Congress passed the Orphan Drug Act (Pub. L. 97-414) to address
the unmet need to develop new treatments, diagnostics and cures for rare diseases
and disorders. The Act created financial incentives such as marketing exclusivity,
tax credits and research grants to encourage the development of orphan drugs.
These incentives were created because it was recognized that the high cost of
research and development, coupled with the low return on investment, discouraged
the pharmaceutical industry from developing products for extremely small patient
populations. A decade later, the Office of Rare Diseases (ORD) was established
within the Office of the Director at the NIH to promote research and collaboration;
bridge the gap between basic and translational research on orphan diseases;
stimulate and coordinate research on rare diseases where none exists; and, take
advantage of scientific opportunities. Since 1993, the ORD has also worked with
other Institutes and Centers to establish research priorities and develop collaborative
research protocols to encourage the exchange of ideas among investigators, voluntary
patient support groups and NIH research staff. All of this work was done with
funding of only $2.1 million in 2001. (Attachment I)
In 1996, the Senate Appropriations Committee requested a report on the coordination
of rare diseases research (Senate Report No. 104-145, pp. 110-111). In response
to that request the NIH convened a Special Emphasis Panel to develop recommendations
for stimulating research on rare diseases and conditions, utilizing research
resources, coordinating rare diseases research and development activities, and
identifying emerging opportunities in rare diseases research. One of the primary
findings of the Panel was that "barriers to rare diseases research"
do exist within the NIH and that there is "inadequate funding for clinical
research" for rare diseases (Summary: Attachment II).
It was not until 2002 when the President's FY 2002 budget narrative for the
NIH called for "additional scientific workshops and regional centers of
excellence for research on rare diseases" that funding was increased to
$10.3 million.
With this increased funding, the ORD published its first Request for Application
(RFA: RR-03-008) on February 27, 2003 (Attachment II). Researchers nationwide
have applied for Rare Diseases Clinical Research Centers and a Data and Technology
Coordinating Center, which together will form the Rare Diseases Clinical Research
Network. The purpose of this cooperative research network "is to facilitate
clinical research in rare diseases."
NORD and the entire rare disease community are deeply indebted to this Committee
for its commitment and its continuing support. This support is vital to the
rare disease community, but it assumes even greater significance when we remember
that "understanding the pathogenesis of rare diseases may advance our understanding
of more common medical disorders."
Dr. Frances Collins, director of the National Human Genome Research Institute,
may have said it best when asked to comment about the discovery of the progeria
gene this past April: "The implications of our work may extend far beyond
progeria to each and every human being. What we learn about the molecular basis
of this model of premature aging may provide us with a better understanding
of what occurs in the body as we all grow older."
Today, twenty years after the passage of the Orphan Drug Act, I am
here to ask that this Committee renew its commitment to the 25 million Americans
affected by rare diseases, and also millions of others nationwide affected by
more common diseases who may someday benefit from the research conducted on
rare diseases. I am asking that the Office of Rare Diseases at the National
Institutes of Health (NIH) be funded as authorized by the Rare Diseases
Act, H.R. 4013, which was introduced by Representative John Shimkus and
signed into law by President Bush on November 6, 2002 (Pub. L. 107-280) as follows:
Office of Rare Diseases
SEC. 404F. (a) Establishment. - There is established within the Office of
the Director of NIH an office to be known as the Office of Rare Diseases (in
this section referred to as the 'Office'), which shall be headed by a Director
(in this section referred to as the 'Director'), appointed by the Director
of NIH.
(d) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS. - $4 million for each of five years.
Rare Diseases Regional Centers of Excellence
SEC. 404G. (a) The Director of the Office of Rare Diseases (in this section
referred to as the 'Director'), in collaboration with the directors of the
other relevant institutes and centers of the National Institutes of Health,
may enter into cooperative agreements with and make grants to public or private
nonprofit entities to pay all or part of the cost of planning, establishing,
or strengthening, and providing basic operating support for regional centers
of excellence for clinical research into, training in, and demonstration of
diagnostic, prevention, control, and treatment methods for rare diseases.
(e) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS. - $20 million for each of five years.
Again, thank you for your continuing commitment to the National Institutes
of Health and your recognition today of the unmet needs of those who suffer
with rare "orphan" diseases.
NORD is a unique federation of voluntary health organizations and over 5,000
individual patients, healthcare providers and clinical researchers dedicated
to helping people with rare "orphan" diseases and assisting the organizations
that serve them. NORD is committed to the identification, treatment, and cure
of rare disorders through programs of education, advocacy, research, and service.
Attachment I
Office of Rare Diseases
National Institutes of Health
Funding Levels, 1996 to Present

Attachment II
SPECIAL EMPHASIS PANEL OF THE NIH ON THE COORDINATION
OF
RARE DISEASES RESEARCH
SUMMARY
January 2001
Language from the United States Senate Appropriations Committee report on the
budget of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) for Fiscal Year 1996 requested
a report on the coordination of rare diseases research. The specific language
follows:
"The Committee recognizes that NIH makes considerable resources
available to support research on the rare diseases and conditions. The Committee
requests that the Office of Rare Disease Research, working jointly with the
research institutes and centers of the NIH, and other Federal agencies with
recommendations from voluntary health organizations, and the pharmaceutical
and biotechnology industries prepare and submit to the Committee prior to
the hearings for fiscal year 1997 a report on steps to coordinate rare disease
research programs within existing research funds and resources." (Senate
Report Number 104-145, pages 110-111)
To respond to this request, NIH, through its Office of Rare Diseases (ORD),
convened a Special Emphasis Panel. The Panel met on May 27-28, 1997, and again
on March 30, 1998, and developed recommendations for stimulating research on
rare diseases and conditions, utilizing research resources, coordinating rare
diseases research and development activities, and identifying emerging opportunities
in rare diseases research. This report presents the Panel's recommendations
developed at its last meeting. Also attached as an appendix to this report is
a copy of the mandated annual report to the DHHS Orphan Products Board on the
rare diseases and conditions research activities of the NIH for 1999. This appended
report highlights the rare diseases and conditions research efforts in most
of the NIH Institutes and Centers for that year, many of which were the subject
of the Special Emphasis Panel's review.
RECOMMENDATIONS
STIMULATING RESEARCH ON RARE DISEASES AND CONDITIONS
| A. |
Emphasis on Research of Rare Diseases and Conditions.
Recommendation: The NIH should continually highlight the significance
and importance of clinical research to medicine and health and emphasize
that an investigator might conduct basic, clinical, or translational research
dedicated to a single rare disorder or a group of related rare disorders
over a lifetime career. |
| B. |
Resources for Training Programs. Recommendation: Resources
currently available for specific training programs should highlight the
opportunities in rare diseases research. |
| C. |
Impact of Managed Care on Clinical Research. Recommendation:
The ORD should participate in the NIH panel on managed care and clinical
research to identify financial barriers to clinical research. |
| D. |
The Peer Review Process. Recommendation: Special emphasis
should be placed on recruiting scientists experienced in specific rare diseases
or conditions to participate in the review of grant applications, onsite-visit
teams, and as active participants in advisory council proceedings. The ORD
and the Center for Scientific Review at NIH should make special efforts
to recruit qualified academic scientists in these areas to participate in
the grant review process. |
| E. |
Membership on Advisory Councils. Recommendation: Representatives
from voluntary patient support groups should be actively recruited to serve
as members of advisory councils at the NIH. |
| F. |
Patient Participation in Clinical Research - Travel to the Research
Site. Recommendation: The NIH should provide sufficient resources
for travel expenses to patients participating in rare diseases research.
The NIH should make information readily available about sources of air travel
to research and treatment sites. |
| G. |
Scientific Workshops and Symposia. Recommendation: The
NIH and the ORD should expand existing programs to provide support for scientific
workshops and symposia to identify research opportunities and to stimulate
research in rare diseases and conditions. |
| H. |
Patient Privacy. Recommendation: Privacy and confidentiality
must be maintained in all aspects of participation in clinical research
studies, genetic testing and counseling services, and treatment programs. |
UTILIZING RESEARCH RESOURCES
| A. |
Availability of Research Resources. Recommendation:
The NIH should emphasize the availability of research resources supported
by the Institutes and Centers of the NIH. A centralized information database
containing research resources should be developed and made available to
research investigators, physicians and patients for their use. |
| B. |
Scientific Materials, Animal Models and Data Dissemination. Recommendation:
The NIH should develop a program to subsidize and facilitate the development
and distribution of reagents, animal models including "knock out mice"
for rare genetic diseases, and materials for research on rare diseases. |
| C. |
Access to Patented Genetic Materials and the Patent Process. Recommendation:
The appropriate organization(s) at the NIH and elsewhere should investigate
and evaluate the effect on rare diseases research of patents on genetic
material. If flaws exist in the current system, they should be addressed
by the appropriate Federal organization. |
| D. |
The General Clinical Research Centers (GCRC) Program. Recommendation:
The panel considers the continued operation of the GCRC program as an essential
component of research in the United States, especially for genetic disorders
and inborn errors of metabolism. Health care providers and the public should
have ready access to information on planned and ongoing clinical research
studies conducted at the NIH supported GCRCs. |
COORDINATION OF RARE DISEASES RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES
| A. |
Advisory Group on Rare Diseases Research. Recommendation:
The NIH should establish an advisory group to the Director, ORD, to provide
recommendations for program activities and to serve as a public forum to
discuss needs and issues of the rare diseases community. |
| B. |
Establish a Permanent Presence for the Office of Rare Diseases
at the National Institutes of Health. Recommendation: The NIH should
review the existing mechanisms to establish a permanent presence for the
ORD and its activities at the NIH |
| C. |
The Orphan Products Board and the Food and Drug Administration.
Recommendation: The Orphan Products Board (OPB) of the DHHS should
develop procedures to solicit advice from the rare diseases community. |
IDENTIFYING EMERGING OPPORTUNITIES IN RARE DISEASES RESEARCH
| A. |
Specialized Centers of Research and Diagnosis of Rare
Diseases. Recommendation: NIH should support the establishment
of Specialized Research and Diagnostic Centers of Excellence for Rare Diseases
to stimulate research and aid in the diagnosis of rare diseases. Specialized
Research and Diagnostic Centers of Excellence for Rare Diseases should be
established on a graduated basis starting with ten regional centers the
first year with incremental increases of ten centers per year until 40 research
centers of excellence are established. |
| B. |
Small Business Innovative Research/Small Business Technology Transfer
(SBIR/STTR) Programs. Recommendation: The NIH should emphasize
the need for research advances and products for the prevention, diagnosis
and treatment of rare diseases in SBIR/STTR publications and announcements. |
| C. |
Gaining Access to Reliable Information. Recommendation:
The NIH and Principal Investigators should update the Computer Retrieval
of Information on Scientific Projects (CRISP) summary abstracts of active
grants, contracts and cooperative agreements to include changes in research
direction or protocols. The term "rare disease" should be included
in the CRISP thesaurus vocabulary as an identifier for research projects. |
| D. |
Gene Vector Development. Recommendation: The FDA, NIH,
the research community and the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries
should collaborate to facilitate the development of gene vectors to be used
for all rare genetic diseases. |
A complete copy of the report may be accessed through the Office of Rare Diseases
web site at http://www.rarediseases.info.nih.gov.